This might, as usual, be a stupid question, but I’m having a hard time finding an exact answer.
I recently got the Aeotec hub, so wanted to try a Zigbee sensor. Start out cheap, so I got a set of Frient sensors. They seem to work great, except… I wanted to try them outside at my garage, but over there is a Zigbee Sonoff bridge. The Frients are no friends with Sonoff apparently, they won’t link up.
But now I was wondering, if you expand your Zigbee mesh by other devices, does the brand of those devices matter, or will they connect anything that’s compatible with the primary hub?
For example, if I expand the aeotec hub, with sonoff plugs and switches, would the Frient sensor suddenly pair with them? Or will they refuse the same as the Sonoff bridge?
Technically all devices should work with each other. Zigbee is a standard that should allow that.
However, real world experience says that is not the case.
For example, the Xiaomi Aqara sensors are zigbee sensors, but don’t follow the zigbee protocol as they should and because of that they don’t work with all repeaters properly. They would drop off the network etc when they met repeaters they didn’t like. They work well with the ikea devices though.
Also try to avoid light bulbs that also act as zigbee repeaters. When power is cut to them, it causes issues with the mesh. I personally have senglend bulbs in my basement. They are zigbee but don’t repeat the signal.
I also try to stick to more known brands now (other than aqara which is very popular due to price). But lately found myself getting more zwave devices. They also have their own bag of issues too.
The Sonoff Zigbee Bridge acts as its own hub – basically, it acts as its own Zigbee network (it’s not joined to your main Zigbee network, so it can’t repeat the signal).
From a quick Google search, it looks like there’s aftermarket firmware that turns the Sonoff Zigbee Bridge into a ‘router’ – eg. a device which you can pair to your main network and it can repeat signals, strengthening the mesh. I have not tried this and I’m not recommending it… just thought I would share it for education purposes.
Back to your original question, generally the brand of the device doesn’t matter for how good it is at expanding your network. As @GavinCampbell mentioned, there are some devices out there that don’t follow specs well and can cause trouble on your network (the older Aqara devices being some of those), so you’d want to avoid those unless you’ve carefully planned for that implication.
As he alluded to, some devices extend the zigbee mesh by repeating signals and others won’t. Generally the devices that repeat the signal indicate themselves as ‘routers’, ‘repeaters’ or similar.
Mains powered devices (eg. devices plugged into constant power) are ideal repeaters. Some bulbs act like repeaters, so you’ll want to be careful with those choices. Bulbs that act as repeaters only really make sense when they are hardwired with power supplied (eg. in a lamp that has the switch removed / taped over) otherwise they can mess with your mesh when they are physically switched off. Wall switches, power plugs, and similar devices are good choices for repeaters.
I know the Sonoff doesn’t repeat the signal, I’ll try to be more specific.
Situation now, the Frients don’t pair with the Sonoff bridge, but they do with the Aeotec hub.
What I wonder, I remove the Sonoff bridge altogether. But instead I install some Sonoff powerplugs.
Will the Sonoff plugs, repeat an exact copy of the Aeotec hub and pair with the Frient.
Or will they put out their own version of the signal and refuse the Frient, like the Sonoff bridge?
Or is it a, yes in theory, but you’ll see when you try?
From a quick search, it’s hard to tell if these make for good repeaters or not. When searching the Amazon reviews of the Sonoff Zigbee Plugs for ‘zigbee repeater’, the reviews are all over the board with some people saying they’re great, but lots of people saying they make for terrible repeaters.
Ps, I’m a bit confused and dissapointed with the Zigbee story.
I also noticed, when selecting Hero attribute, the Sonoff sensors connected to the Aeotec hub report their battery status. The ones connected to their own Sonoff bridge, don’t…