Hi @Jamison, welcome to the community. Setting auto-off in the Virtual Switch to make it behave like a button is actually not uncommon. You may also be interested to checked out the Virtual Momentary Switch device handler developed by @Bloodtick_Jones.
Once you create this virtual momentary device, authorize it to SharpTools, and add it to the dashboard, you can edit the tile and change the layout to the Momentary Tile as described in the release note below and you can just tap it to trigger the associated rule and not having to track the switch’s state.
Is this what you are looking for?